The episode originally aired on September 8th, 1966. For the original pilot I figure it too could be confusing. Perhaps in the sixties everyone didn’t need everything explained. I guess it’s something that we expect in a show now. Lead us by the hand and make sure we know what’s going on or we won’t come back.
The story was, again, interesting. A chameleon-like killer fools everyone and before you know it crew members are turning up dead. The conflict comes from McCoy’s past with and love of a woman, Nancy, who also turns out to be the chameleon.
I believe I will be a diehard Kirk fan, though at heart I’ll always be a Science Officer. Shatner performs the role very nicely. A few small appearances from Sulu are also welcoming!
The effects in this episode were much better. Seeing the Enterprise in space is also a nice feature, though I do believe it is an inclusion into the remastering of the series for the most part. The costumes of the creatures are very clever for the time the show was produced. Also the hand-puppet flower was amusing.
The episode was enjoyable and I’m glad all of the major characters were there from the very first episode.